Credit: Photo by The Polzel Group | Source


Homes for Sale in Benton Harbor, Mount Juliet, TN

Benton Harbor is a small but wonderful lake community in the northern section of Mount Juliet, Tennessee.

Its desirable location is a gateway to Old Hickory Lake, with some properties having direct access to the waters. Benton Harbor homes feature all-brick exteriors with a classic look and feel. The open floor plan creates an airy, spacious atmosphere perfect for entertaining friends and family. The residences also have beautiful outdoor spaces, such as decks and gazebos, that take advantage of the breathtaking vistas and natural beauty. Have a relaxing view of the calm waters or verdant preserves and experience serenity, ideal for unwinding after a busy day. The lake is within walking distance which also means proximity to water-based activities. The bustling metropolis of Nashville is accessible within a 35-minute drive, so locals can still enjoy living in a small town while having access to big-city amenities.

LAKEFRONT DWELLINGS: Lakefront living provides a unique and unforgettable experience many people dream of having. The picturesque view from your deck is awe-inspiring and offers a serene, relaxing environment. The reservoir is also perfect for water-based activities like swimming and boating. Walk to the creek and bask in an early morning fishing or bring your kayak anytime with little effort. It’s a great place to start a family, create lasting memories, and enjoy an active lifestyle.

PRIVACY: One of the significant benefits of residing in Benton Harbor, Mt Juliet, TN, is the privacy that comes with it. The well-spaced homes and cul-de-sac lots create a feeling of exclusivity, providing much-needed solitude to relax and recharge. The houses are well-positioned and back up to the lake or the lush forests, so you have limited neighbors, making it ideal for those who prefer a quiet environment with fewer distractions. You can enjoy your private oasis while being part of a friendly and welcoming community.

RURAL FEEL: The beautiful landscape provides a tranquil ambiance perfect for those who appreciate the countryside. Lounge in your wooded backyard and immerse yourself in the natural beauty while bird-watching or visit the nearby Cedar Creek Campground and Boxwell Reservation. These are inviting destinations for outdoor enthusiasts who want to engage in adventure-filled activities such as hiking, camping, and fishing. Live slowly, reconnect with nature, and enjoy a simple, peaceful life.

Market Overview

Mount Juliet, TN Real Estate Information

Median Listing Price


Median Price Per Sq Ft


Average Days on Market


Median Price of Sold Homes


Home Ownership Percentage


Median Rent


Homes in Benton Harbor, Mount Juliet, TN

5 Real Estate Facts About Benton Harbor Homes

  • Lovely Benton Harbor homes for sale are primarily constructed in the 2020s.
  • Previously sold single-family homes are valued from $660,000 to $880,000.
  • Total living space can be anywhere from 3,190 sq ft. to 5,282 sq ft.
  • Dwellings in the neighborhood sit on lots ranging from 0.83 to 3.26 acres offering the ultimate privacy and seclusion.
  • These extraordinary houses offer unique floor plans with three to four bedrooms and three to four bathroom layouts.
Homes for Sale

Benton Harbor, TN Homes For Sale

On the map

Benton Harbor, Mount Juliet, TN Map

Benton Harbor is east of Benders Ferry Rd and is accessible through Hwy 109 and Lebanon Rd. A portion of its southern section sits directly on the waters of Old Hickory Lake, flowing through Lone Branch. There is only one entry to the neighborhood via Benton Harbor Blvd.

Take the next step

Ready to take the next step?

When we say that we are out to make clients for life, we mean it! The Polzel Group goes above and beyond — not just to help you find a house, but to make sure it’s the right house for you and your needs. WHETHER IT’S YOUR FIRST TIME BUYING A HOME, OR YOUR THIRD, IT’S STILL A BIG DEAL. As your trusted advisor, we will be there for you every step of the way. This frees you to focus on the one thing that nobody but you can do — pick the house that feels right. We’re here to do everything else.

Meet the locals

Who Lives in Mount Juliet, TN



Median Age


Median Household Income




Household size


Cost of living



Things to do near Benton Harbor, Mount Juliet, TN

Cedar Creek Marina

Spend a day outdoors and enjoy a range of recreational opportunities for boating enthusiasts, including boat rentals, slip rentals, fuel, and boat repairs.

Boxwell Scout Reservation

A camping destination that provides outdoor activities for everyone, such as fishing, swimming, hiking, and shooting sports.

Orangetheory Fitness

Stay fit with the gym's unique workout experience combining science, coaching, and technology to help members achieve their fitness goals.

Smiley Thai and Sushi

Savor delicious Thai and Japanese cuisine like Pad Thai, Tom Yum, and bento boxes in a cozy and friendly atmosphere.


Schools near Benton Harbor, Mount Juliet, TN

School NameGradesAdmission
West Elementary SchoolK - 5Public
Mt. Juliet Middle School6 - 8Public
Mt. Juliet High School9 - 12Public